Delhi HC prioritises refinery continuity over IT disruption; SAP told to keep Nayara Energy services running

  • Division Bench directs continuation of critical enterprise software services pending appeal
  • Court recognises SAP infrastructure as vital to uninterrupted refinery operations
  • Nayara warns that abrupt withdrawal could trigger cybersecurity risks and operational disruptions
  • Alternative ERP migration may take years and cost hundreds of crores

NE LAW & BUSINESS BUREAU

NEW DELHI, NOV 17

In a significant reprieve for Nayara Energy, the Delhi High Court has refused to grant SAP any interim relief against an earlier direction to restore critical software support services to the oil refiner, ensuring that its enterprise technology backbone remains operational while the legal battle continues.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Prathiba M. Singh and Justice Dinesh Bhatt, while issuing notice on SAP’s appeal, directed the software major to continue providing services in accordance with the Single Judge’s earlier order. The Bench declined to grant any interim stay, thereby preserving the existing arrangement in favour of Nayara Energy.

In its November 5 order, the Division Bench orally observed that the “SAP system could be considered an essential service for Nayara’s refinery operations”, pointing out that replacing the entire IT architecture at short notice was not feasible.

The development follows a September order by a Single Judge Bench headed by Justice Vikas Mahajan, directing SAP to immediately restore critical support services to Nayara Energy.

Nayara Energy, which meets approximately 8% of India’s fuel requirement, had approached the court contending that the withdrawal of SAP’s support services exposed its critical IT infrastructure to potential system failures, cybersecurity vulnerabilities and serious operational disruptions.

The company argued that shifting to an alternative Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) platform would be a prolonged and capital-intensive exercise, potentially taking several years and involving expenditure running into hundreds of crores. It maintained that uninterrupted SAP support was indispensable for business continuity, operational stability and regulatory compliance.

In his detailed 120-page order, Justice Mahajan had underscored the risks associated with discontinuing technical support for a software ecosystem underpinning critical industrial operations.

Emphasising the importance of continuity in technology support for infrastructure of this scale, the Single Judge observed: “For critical infrastructure of this scale, an uninterrupted flow of technical support services is absolutely essential”.

The latest direction represents an important interim advantage for Nayara Energy, as the High Court has prioritised continuity of critical software services over any immediate disruption arising from the ongoing contractual and legal dispute. It also ensures that the company’s refinery-related IT ecosystem remains supported while SAP pursues its appeal.

The matter is now scheduled to come up for further hearing on January 11, 2027.

 

Leave a Reply