NE LEGAL BUREAU
NEW DELHI, AUG 24
The Supreme Court on Monday disposed of as “infructuous” a BJP MLA’s plea seeking stay on Rajasthan Speaker’s decision, which allowed six BSP MLAs to merge with the Congress, in view of the High Court order.
A bench of Justices Arun Mishra, Vineet Saran, and M R Shah was informed by senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the Speaker, that earlier in the day that the Rajasthan High Court has passed an order on the plea filed by BJP MLA Madan Dilawar.
He said the high court has asked the Speaker to decide on merit, the plea against the merger of six BSP MLAs with the ruling Congress.
Sibal said the high court had also asked the speaker to decide on the matter within three months.
The bench said the plea before it was against an interim order of the high court, and has now become infructuous.
On August 17, the top court had deferred the hearing on Dilawar’s plea after it was informed that the Chief Justice of the High Court has reportedly tested positive for COVID-19 and the functioning was postponed till August 19.
Earlier, the top court had refused to pass any interim order on the plea after it was informed that the high court has been dealing with the case.
The BJP lawmaker said the six Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) MLAs have been wrongly allowed by the Speaker to merge with the ruling Congress party.
Dilawar challenged the high court order which had refused to stay the functioning of these six MLAs as Congress legislators.
Earlier, the apex court had allowed the withdrawal of a petition filed by six Rajasthan MLAs of BSP seeking transfer of the plea pending against them in the high court to the apex court.
Senior advocate Harish Salve, appearing for Dilawar, had said that the matter can go on before the high court but the issue is what is to be done in the meantime.
Salve, while referring to the September last year order of merger passed by the Speaker, had said there is a “curious situation” as the BSP is saying that they have not merged.
He had said that the apex court should stay the Speaker’s order of September last year.
Senior advocate S C Mishra, appearing for the BSP, had said the six MLAs had gone to the Speaker saying they want to merge and the order for the merger was passed “straight away”.
He had said in the Rajasthan Assembly also, these MLAs are not following the whip of the BSP; moreover, it is a national party and split, if any, has to be at the national level.
Dilawar has challenged in the apex court the August 6 order of a division bench of the high court which disposed of his plea against the order of a single judge, who had refused to stay the functioning of these six MLAs as Congress legislators.
The single judge of the high court had earlier not granted any interim relief and refused to put a stay on the participation of six MLAs in the proceedings of the House as Congress legislators.
On July 30, the high court had sought response of the Assembly Speaker and its secretary on the pleas challenging the induction of the six MLAs into the Congress.
Two petitions have been filed in the high court, one by Dilawar and the other by BSP National Secretary S C Mishra.
Sandeep Yadav, Wajib Ali, Deepchand Kheria, Lakhan Meena, Jogendra Awana, and Rajendra Gudha contested and won the 2018 assembly election on a BSP ticket but they defected to Congress in September 2019.
They had submitted an application for the merger on September 16 last year and the Speaker allowed their induction into the Congress two days later.
The merger was a boost to the Ashok Gehlot-led government as the tally of the Congress increased to 107 in the house of 200.
Dilawar has challenged the merger of the BSP MLAs into Congress, questioning Assembly Speaker CP Joshi”s order dismissing his complaint without allowing him to have his say.
Mishra has challenged in the high court the defection of the MLAs, but these legislators had not sought transfer of his plea to the Supreme Court.
HC asks Rajasthan Assembly speaker to decide BJP MLA’s plea against merger of BSP MLAs
The Rajasthan High Court on Monday asked the state assembly speaker to decide on merit a writ petition filed by BJP MLA Madan Dilawar against the merger of six BSP MLAs with the ruling Congress.
The court asked the speaker to decide on the matter within three months.
A single-judge bench of Justice Mahendra Kumar Goyal, while disposing of the writ petition filed by Dilawar, asked him to approach the assembly speaker.
The court asked the speaker to decide the complaint, which was filed by Dilawar on March 16, afresh.
“The court disposed Madan Dilawar’s writ petition and has asked the assembly speaker to conduct hearing in the complaint filed on March 16 and decide the matter on merit within three months,” a counsel for the speaker said.
The detailed order of the court is awaited.
Dilawar had filed the writ petition in the high court to challenge the merger of six MLAs- Sandeep Yadav, Wajib Ali, Deepchand Kheria, Lakhan Meena, Jogendra Awana, and Rajendra Gudha- with the Congress and demanded a stay on the execution on the order passed by the speaker.
The six MLAs had contested and won the 2018 assembly elections on BSP tickets and defected to the Congress in September 2019.
The MLAs submitted an application for a merger on September 16, 2019, and the Speaker issued an order on September 18, 2019.
Challenging the merger, Dilawar had filed a petition before the speaker in March which was rejected on July 24.
